Growing and Retaining Your IT Talent

Employer Guides · Guide 6 of 6

How to keep great people growing and contributing over the long term.

Retaining great people is just as important as hiring them. This guide explores practical ways to support career growth, strengthen engagement, develop future leaders, and create a workplace where IT professionals can thrive and contribute over the long term.

Estimated reading time: 11 minutes.

Key takeaways

  • Retaining strong IT talent is significantly cheaper than replacing it. The total cost of turnover in IT roles is typically 1.5 to 3 times annual salary.
  • Career development in IT is not one-size-fits-all. Understand what growth means to each individual.
  • Technical career pathways that don't require people management are essential for retaining deep specialists.
  • Tools and systems that are fit for purpose are a retention factor, not just a productivity issue.
  • Culture in a hybrid or distributed team requires deliberate effort. It doesn't happen by accident.
  • Performance feedback that develops rather than just evaluates is one of the strongest drivers of engagement and retention.

Structured Career Development for IT Roles

Career development in IT is one of the most commonly cited retention factors, and one of the most commonly mishandled. The organisations that get it right treat it as a structured, ongoing conversation, not a once-a-year performance review exercise.

The Mistake Most Organisations Make

The most common failure in IT career development is treating it as synonymous with promotion. Many organisations have clear pathways for people who want to move into management, and almost nothing for those who want to grow as technical specialists. This creates a structural problem: your best technical people either move into management, where they may be less effective and less fulfilled, or they leave for organisations that recognise and reward technical excellence.

What Effective Career Development Looks Like

Two consistent patterns emerge from the organisations that retain IT talent effectively:

Individual goal setting that starts with open questions

At the start of each year (or at relevant intervals), a structured conversation that doesn’t start with ‘what do you want to be doing in five years?’ but with more focused options:

  • Do you want to improve technically? If so, in which direction?
  • Are you aiming for a leadership role, either technical or people? If so, what would need to be true before you felt ready?
  • Do you want to expand your exposure to different parts of the business or different types of work?
  • Are you happy in your current scope but want to go deeper or broader within it?

A roadmap that makes the path visible

Once the individual’s goal direction is understood, the conversation should produce a concrete plan: what skills need to be developed, what experiences would accelerate the goal, and what support the organisation will provide to make it possible.

Technical Career Pathways

For organisations that want to retain strong technical specialists, a defined technical career pathway is essential. This creates a recognised route for people who want to grow their expertise without managing others:

Level Characteristics
Junior / Graduate Learning core skills in the specialisation. Working under close supervision. Building foundational knowledge.
Mid-level Working with increasing independence. Contributing to design decisions. Beginning to mentor more junior team members.
Senior Leading technical work within a project or domain. Recognised expertise. Beginning to influence technical direction.
Principal / Lead Defining technical approach across multiple projects or domains. Significant influence on technology strategy. Peer to senior management on technical matters.
Distinguished / Fellow Organisation-wide technical authority. External recognition in the field. Sets technical direction for the organisation.

Optimising Tooling and Workplace Systems

IT professionals are more attuned than most employees to the quality of the tools and systems they work with. The right tools don’t just improve productivity. They signal that the organisation takes its technical work seriously.

The Tool Problem Most Organisations Underestimate

Many organisations invest in tools but underinvest in the education and enablement needed to use them well. This creates a situation where teams have access to powerful technology that delivers a fraction of its potential value because people don’t know how to use it effectively. Every new tool release, every feature update, every platform change needs accompanying investment in education, not just access.

It’s really easy to give people tools to try and make them more productive. But if you haven’t kept up with the education around how those tools work, if they get updates and nobody’s learned what’s changed, you’re failing your team. Throwing ten tools at someone or throwing two doesn’t matter if you’re not using them properly. Sian Clements, Younity

Principles for Effective Tooling Decisions

  • Involve the team in tooling decisions. The people doing the work understand what they need better than management does. Mandating tools without input creates resistance and poor adoption.
  • Fewer tools, used well, are usually better than many tools used poorly. Tooling sprawl creates cognitive overhead and integration problems.
  • Budget for enablement, not just licences. The cost of a tool subscription is rarely the largest cost. The time needed to use it effectively, and to maintain and support it, often is.
  • Regularly review the tool stack. Tools that were the right choice two years ago may no longer be. An annual review of what’s being used, how, and whether it’s delivering value prevents the accumulation of tools that nobody uses.

IT Professionals’ Relationship with Their Tools

For many IT professionals, particularly developers and engineers, their tools are not just productivity instruments. They are part of their professional identity. Being forced to work with outdated, poorly maintained, or restricted technology is a genuine retention risk for technically strong people who know what good looks like. When evaluating your technology environment from a retention perspective, ask:

  • Are our tools current enough that our team can learn from the broader professional community, or have we locked them into something proprietary and limiting?
  • Do our security and governance policies prevent people from doing the work they need to do, or do they enable it while managing risk appropriately?
  • Are we giving people access to the AI and productivity tools that are becoming standard in the field?

Culture Building for Hybrid Environments

Team culture in a hybrid environment does not maintain itself. It requires deliberate attention and active investment from both leaders and team members.

What Hybrid Culture Requires

Building and maintaining a strong team culture in a hybrid environment involves three things that don’t happen automatically:

Intentional connection

The informal connection that happens naturally when people work in the same space needs to be designed for in a hybrid environment. Regular team rituals, not all work-focused, maintain the social fabric. A monthly team lunch, a quarterly offsite, a weekly informal check-in that’s not about the work. These need to be protected on the calendar, not cancelled when things get busy.

Equitable participation

In hybrid meetings, people in the physical room often have an advantage over those joining remotely. This creates a two-tier dynamic where remote participants are less engaged and less visible. Solutions: either everyone joins remotely (hybrid call policy), or meetings are designed specifically for in-person, with remote participation handled differently.

Visible leadership

Leaders who are rarely visible to the full team, either because they’re always in the office while the team is remote, or vice versa, lose connection with their teams quickly. Deliberate visibility across both contexts, including being occasionally remote when the team is remote and in-person when they are, signals equity.

What are practical ways to build team culture when people are working in different places? You have to create the rituals deliberately. And when things get busy, those rituals are the first thing that gets cancelled. That’s exactly when you shouldn’t cancel them. Culture is built in those moments. Amanda, Younity

Performance Feedback That Lifts Motivation

Feedback is one of the most powerful tools available to managers, and one of the most underused. IT professionals in particular benefit from feedback that is specific, honest, and constructive, and many don’t receive nearly enough of it.

What Makes Feedback Effective

Effective performance feedback has several consistent characteristics:

Quality What it looks like in practice
Specific Not ‘your communication could be better’ but ‘in the sprint review last Thursday, the way you explained the API changes left the product team unclear about what was changing and why. Here’s what I’d suggest instead.’
Timely Feedback given at the time, or soon after an event, is significantly more useful than feedback delivered months later in an annual review.
Balanced Highlighting what’s working well is not just nice. It tells people what to do more of, which is as valuable as telling them what to do differently.
Two-way The best performance conversations involve genuine dialogue. What does the employee think? What do they need? The manager’s observation is an input to the conversation, not the final word.
Focused on growth Feedback framed around development (‘here’s what would make you more effective’) is received differently from feedback framed as criticism (‘here’s what’s wrong with what you did’).

 

Adapting Feedback to Different Working Styles

IT teams contain people with widely different communication preferences. Some developers and engineers, particularly those who are more introverted or neurodivergent, can find direct feedback conversations confrontational, even when the content is fair and reasonable. This doesn’t mean softening the feedback. It means being thoughtful about the format:

  • For those who prefer written communication, sending feedback in written form before a conversation allows time to process.
  • For those who find face-to-face conversations confrontational, a Teams or phone conversation can sometimes be easier than an in-person meeting.
  • For all people, separating the feedback from a performance rating conversation allows the development content to be heard on its own terms.

I think it comes back to honesty without being harsh. People don’t have the opportunity to improve if they don’t know what’s wrong. And with developers, who can be quite introverted, you’ve got to find a way to communicate that’s not too confronting. Tailor it to the EQ of the person. Amanda, Younity

Retention as a Lever for Productivity and Cost Control

Retaining strong IT talent is not just a people management priority. It is a financial and operational one. Understanding the true cost of turnover helps organisations make the case for investment in retention.

The True Cost of IT Turnover

When a strong IT professional leaves, the visible cost is the recruitment fee. The total cost is significantly higher:

Cost Component What it includes
Recruitment cost Agency fees (typically 15 to 20% of first-year salary for specialist roles), job advertising, internal recruiter time.
Productivity gap The period of reduced output while the role is vacant. For technical roles that are critical dependencies, this can create project delays with significant business impact.
Onboarding cost Time and resources invested in getting the replacement up to speed. For senior technical roles, this is typically three to six months before the person is fully effective.
Knowledge loss The institutional knowledge, relationships, and context that leaves with the person. This is rarely fully captured in documentation and takes time to rebuild.
Team impact Departures affect team morale and can trigger further departures, particularly if the person leaving is respected and their reasons for leaving resonate with others.
Management time The time leaders spend managing a vacancy, a hiring process, and an onboarding process instead of doing their actual work.

 

Retention Is Not Just About Keeping People Comfortable

An important nuance: retaining people is most valuable when those people are growing, engaged, and delivering value. Retaining people who have stopped learning and are coasting out of comfort, or who have become disengaged but remain because change feels like too much effort, does not serve the organisation’s interests. The goal is an environment where strong, engaged people want to stay because it’s the right place for them, not one where people stay because they’re too comfortable to leave.

Retaining people just to keep your churn levels down, because that person is comfortable and knows what they’re doing, that’s not the right reason to hang on to people. If you can see your people continuing to be better and continuing to bring their best, there’s every reason to hang on to them. But the goal is people who want to stay because they’re growing, not people who stay because leaving seems like too much effort. Sian Clements, Younity

The Retention Levers

The most reliable retention levers for IT professionals, in rough order of impact:

  1. Interesting and meaningful work. People stay where the work is engaging and where they can see the impact of what they do.
  2. Growth and development. Visible pathways to learning, progression, and increased capability.
  3. Quality of management. A direct manager who is responsive, fair, and genuinely invested in the person’s success.
  4. Team and culture. Connection to colleagues and alignment with the organisation’s values and ways of working.
  5. Flexibility and autonomy. The ability to manage their own time and environment to some meaningful degree.
  6. Compensation. Competitive and fair. Not necessarily the highest in the market, but within a range that feels reasonable for the value being provided.

Further Reading